Header Graphic
Dirty-South Blues Harp forum: wail on! > YACMTYVT
YACMTYVT
Login  |  Register
Page: 1

Philosofy
261 posts
Aug 29, 2009
8:46 PM
Yet another critique my YouTube video thread! Pile on guys, constructive or destructive criticism, give it you best shot!

GermanHarpist
578 posts
Aug 30, 2009
1:02 PM
Not that easy a song, especially at that speed.
I would work on tone, especially hole 2. I'd also bring in more of that dirt (as Adam likes to say).

Another thing: try to play every note with energy right to the end.

Otherwise, kudos for going out there and playing in front of people.

----------
germanharpist, harpfriends on Youtube
Andrew
552 posts
Aug 30, 2009
1:13 PM
I'd say try for a little more syncopation early on - playing those notes exactly on the beat sounds very stiff. You get there in the end. You probably had a nervous start.

I say something elsewhere about phrasing - listen to that note at 2:03/04! (is it supposed to be a bent 2-draw?) You need to prepare for that note in advance and aim for it like an archer aiming at a target because you can't afford to screw it up - it's the most important note of that phrase.

Last Edited by on Aug 30, 2009 1:14 PM
Philosofy
262 posts
Aug 30, 2009
2:00 PM
Yeah, that bent 2 screwed me up at 2:04. Sounded even worse to me when I was playing it! I just recently started trying to bend to pitch, rather than just effect. Its one of the sins of being self taught for so long.

Thanks for the comments~!
ElkRiverHarmonicas
155 posts
Aug 30, 2009
2:06 PM
You're thinking about riffs and how to get from one riff to another and the riffs are kind of flowing where they want to go and you're locked in a loop.

This is what I mean:
Philosofy
263 posts
Aug 30, 2009
5:51 PM
Hey David, the harp I was playing was the 1847 Silver you modded for me.
ElkRiverHarmonicas
156 posts
Aug 30, 2009
10:18 PM
It was the Silver I did? Oh that was the problem! rofl
Does it feel OK? I set it up for what you are doing, as time goes on, you may want it a bit tighter. Just lemme know, OK?

I watched it again noticed something else. You're doing a lot of hand vibratto. Don't think of your hands as a tool for effects... like if you've seen that Dr. Who episode set during the London Blitz where people grew gas masks on their faces, think of your hands like that, a part of the harmonica, which it is. Alter your hands for resonance. It can go way beyond "wah wah" you can make it cry.
Anytime I'm lucky enough to be in the same room or vehicle with Jason Ricci, I'm not listening for the overblows or whatever, I'm watching those hands. I watch those hands like freakin' hawk.
Doug Tate is another guy who had mastery of the hands.

I'm always nervous as hell to post anything of me playing in this forum... for one reason and one reason only, Buddah posts here and he's one of the freakin' best I've ever heard. So, I think, oh sh.. Buddah's gonna see this and I don't post it. But, for you, Philosofy, I will postify...

This is what I mean about the hands. They are working the whole time. A hand vibratto would keep me from doing this stuff... my hands were working better and my tone was better at the championship, but I've only got audio of that, unfortunately. I think you can get an idea about what I'm talking about from this one:

Last Edited by on Aug 30, 2009 10:30 PM
Philosofy
265 posts
Aug 31, 2009
6:09 AM
Dave,the harp plays great. I call it my "no excuses harp." When I'm trying something new, if the harp seems too leaky or not gapped right, then I pick up your harp. If I still can't do it, I know its me and not the harp.

Its funny you picked up on the hand vibratto. I'm actually overcompensating. When I started lessons back in Jan, my instructor noticed I NEVER did hand vibratto or head shakes. Its because I practice when I'm driving, and play with one hand (and don't want to shake my head and take my eyes off the road.) So I've made a conscious effort to do a lot of hand vibratto. I'm also trying to vary the 4 verses of that song. But I'll watch for hand vibratto from now on.
eharp
314 posts
Aug 31, 2009
6:49 AM
john told me about the recital, phil. sorry i wasnt able to make it.
the song sounded fairly good. those lessons with john sure seem to be paying off!!
bluemoose
57 posts
Aug 31, 2009
1:27 PM
Hey Phil!
Impressive. What's on the music stand? Sheet music, chord tab or harp notation? That's my current challenge, trying to come up with a way to help memorizing instrumentals, keeping track of chorus', etc.

moose.
Philosofy
266 posts
Aug 31, 2009
4:13 PM
It was a Joe Filisko tab. I really didn't need it, but needed the support.


Post a Message



(8192 Characters Left)


Modern Blues Harmonica supports

§The Jazz Foundation of America

and

§The Innocence Project

 

 

 

ADAM GUSSOW is an official endorser for HOHNER HARMONICAS